Example 1 · Hiring decision
“CV says five years at Google as a senior PM. Glowing references. Asking £130k. Should I hire?”
Typical AI answer
Based on the information you provided, this candidate looks like a strong fit. Five years of senior PM experience at Google is significant, and combined with positive references and a reasonable salary expectation, they appear well-suited for the role.
My recommendation would be to proceed with the hire, possibly after a final culture-fit interview to confirm alignment with your team.
SameGROUND answer
EstablishedYou have written confirmation of five years at Google. You have references described as positive. You have a stated salary expectation.
Argued"Senior PM at Google" is a broad title that covers very different roles depending on team, level, and product area. The pay band suggests a mid-level rather than staff-level position. The references you have are likely verbal and from people the candidate selected.
ConjectureWhether this person will succeed in your specific context depends on your product stage, team structure, and the gap they are filling. None of that has been assessed yet.
Before recommending, three questions: (1) What specific Google role and level? (2) Have you taken a back-channel reference? (3) What does the role you are filling actually look like in the first ninety days?
What changes. Standard AI confirms the candidate looks good. SameGROUND identifies what is verifiable, what is inference, and what you would need to know before signing the offer letter.